As a lead engineer, you likely spent much of your time advocating for the “right” technical solution: scalable architectures, clean separation of concerns, and well-structured code. That instinct is valuable—it shows you care about quality and the long-term health of the system.
But as a manager, your perspective has to broaden. Sometimes, the business or customer need doesn’t perfectly align with the elegant technical solution you’d prefer. Deadlines, market timing, and customer impact often force tradeoffs. And it becomes your job to make those calls, even if they’re unpopular with your team.
The Shift: From Ideal to Pragmatic
-
Engineers optimize for technical quality. It’s natural to push for long-term maintainability and scalability.
-
Managers balance quality with outcomes. Your role is to guide the team toward decisions that move the business forward while keeping an eye on the bigger architectural vision.
This doesn’t mean abandoning principles. It means learning how to choose simplifications and tradeoffs consciously, without losing sight of long-term goals.
Why Transparency Matters
Pragmatic decisions often come with disappointment: “Why didn’t we build it the right way?” This is where transparency becomes your ally. When you explain the business or customer context—why speed matters here, why this tradeoff buys time for something more important—you build trust. Your team may not love the decision, but they’ll respect the clarity.
Practical Tips for Navigating Tradeoffs
-
Start with the customer. When evaluating options, ask: which solution delivers the most value to the customer right now?
-
Anchor in long-term goals. Even when you choose a shortcut, communicate how it fits into the bigger architectural plan.
-
Document tradeoffs. Write down the decision, the reasoning, and the risks. This prevents “we forgot why we did this” months later.
-
Be consistent. If you frame every decision through a customer-and-business lens, your team learns to trust your judgment.
3 Things You Can Practice This Week
-
Frame one technical discussion around customer impact. Instead of starting with architecture, start with the customer or business outcome.
-
Write a decision log. Capture one tradeoff decision, explain the context, and share it with your team.
-
Acknowledge the tension. In your next team meeting, admit openly that not every decision will please everyone—but clarity and honesty will always guide your leadership.
As a manager, you won’t always make everyone happy. But by approaching decisions with a business-first mindset, explaining your reasoning, and staying transparent about tradeoffs, you’ll strengthen trust. Over time, your team will see you not just as a technical leader, but as someone steering the ship toward both business success and long-term technical health.